First Touchdown Scorer Props – Who Will Score First TD Tonight?

Kansas City Chiefs wide receiver Rashee Rice (4) celebrates after scoring a touchdown against the Las Vegas Raiders during the fourth quarter at Allegiant Stadium.
Image Credit: Stephen R. Sylvanie-USA TODAY Sports

First touchdown scorer props have become increasingly popular over the years, and it’s easy to see why. They are fun wagers that tend to settle quickly unless you are locked into an old-school defensive struggle.

Below, we’ll run through our favorite first touchdown scorer props. Then, we’ll outline some strategy tips for this special type of bet, which could be helpful if you are new to this specific bet type.

So let’s start with the all-important question: who will be the first touchdown scorer tonight?

First Touchdown Scorer: Super Bowl 58

Below are our favorite first touchdown props for Super Bowl 58.

49ers RB Christian McCaffrey (+400)

McCaffrey is leading the way for San Francisco in the playoffs. He has four touchdowns and 260 yards in just two games on the path to the Super Bowl.

It’s safe to say the Chiefs will have a game plan to contain him, but many teams have most likely thought the same entering a matchup against the 49ers. 

While the Chiefs were able to limit any rushing scores in the AFC Championship game, they still rank 27th in rush DVOA this season. I’m not sure why the Ravens didn’t take advantage of this, but McCaffrey should be able to capitalize.

Where to bet: Christian McCaffrey First TD | +400 at DraftKings Sportsbook

Chiefs WR Rashee Rice (+1000)

Rice has been a consistent target for Patrick Mahomes in each of their three playoff games so far as he has already notched a score in that time.

He caught eight of his twelve targets against the Dolphins, all four of his targets against the Bills, and eight of his nine targets against the Ravens.

With Travis Kelce posing another significant threat, Rice will be the prime target if the 49ers elite defense manages to limit Kelce’s production.

Where to bet: Rashee Rice First TD | +1000 at DraftKings Sportsbook

NFL Player Props Special: Super Bowl 58

This is a no-brainer NFL prop for NEW USERS of Underdog Fantasy for the Super Bowl.


Our partners at Underdog Fantasy are offering a promotion that allows you to take Patrick Mahomes over 0.5 total yards.

  • New customers can also get up to a $100 deposit bonus with promo code PROPS.
  • You can pair this with one of the aforementioned props or use our NFL cheat sheets for help.
  • This presents a fantastic opportunity to boost your bankroll.

More NFL Props For Super Bowl 58

Best NFL Player Props – Top NFL Prop Bets (Super Bowl 58)

NFL Anytime Touchdown Scorer Predictions & Best Bets

Super Bowl Deal: $50 Protected Pick

This is a fantastic promotion for ALL USERS of Sleeper Fantasy for Super Bowl weekend.


Our partners at Sleeper Fantasy are offering up to a $50 protected pick starting Friday, Feb. 9 at 3 pm ET that runs until Super Bowl kickoff. 

  • If you don’t win your entry, they will refund your entry as promo funds up to $50. 
  • The promo will auto-apply to your first contest once the promotion is live (Friday, Feb. 9 at 3 pm ET)
  • You can only use this promotion once. So if you place a $5 contest, you will only have a $5 protected pick.

If you don’t have a Sleeper Fantasy account, you can grab two more bonuses along with the protected pick above. 

  • New user exclusive pick: Patrick Mahomes over 0.5 yards.
  • New customers also get up to a $500 deposit bonus with promo code PROPS.
  • Claiming all three offers presents a fantastic opportunity to boost your bankroll.

Where To Place First Touchdown Scorer Bets

The following sportsbooks have more than enough options to satisfy your first touchdown scorer needs. As outlined before, always shop around for the best price when it comes to first touchdown scorer bets.

On top of that, our team spent the time to find the best available bonus offers at each listed sportsbook. If you are new to any of these betting apps, be sure to use our exclusive links and promo codes to claim your free bets:

Best Sportsbook Bonuses In The U.S.

Find out about the best available online sportsbook bonuses in your state with the following guides:

First Touchdown Scorer Bet Explained

Player prop bets are linked to player production instead of team production. That can make them a bit easier for beginning bettors to digest, especially those with a background in fantasy football.

Typically, most player prop bets involve wagering on whether you believe a player will go over or under a specific number in a particular category. They can include things like passing yardage, receptions, and carries.

However, you can also bet on whether or not you think a player is going to score a touchdown. These bets offer different odds for different players, with the most likely players to score getting the shortest odds

You can read all my analysis about anytime touchdown scorers here.

If those props don’t offer enough upside for you, first touchdown scorer props take things to another level. Instead of winning your bet if your player scores a touchdown at any time, they have to be the first ballcarrier to cross the goal line in a given game. There can only be one first-touchdown scorer in every contest, so it makes these props significantly harder to win.

However, that added risk comes with added upside. You’ll get a far greater payout if you roll the dice on the first touchdown scorer instead of an anytime touchdown scorer.

Do Passing Touchdowns Count For First Touchdown Scorer Props?

Just like with anytime touchdown scorer props, passing touchdowns are not included in first touchdown scorer props. If the first touchdown of a game is a passing touchdown, then whoever caught the ball would be considered the first TD scorer.

However, that doesn’t mean that quarterbacks are irrelevant in first touchdown scorer props. Quarterbacks will run for more touchdowns than you think, especially as more athletic passers enter the league seemingly every year. 23 quarterbacks ran for multiple scores last year, with Jalen Hurts leading the pack at 10. There are some familiar suspects on the list – Hurts, Josh Allen, and Kyler Murray each had at least five rushing touchdowns – but you don’t need to be a great rusher to score touchdowns. Ryan Tannehill was second among quarterbacks with seven touchdowns, while noted statue Tom Brady even had two scores.

Ultimately, quarterbacks were some of the most profitable players last year in any time touchdown scorer props. If quarterbacks are scoring more rushing touchdowns than expected, it stands to reason they’d be underpriced in first-touchdown odds as well.

What Odds Should You Expect With First Touchdown Scorer Props?

This depends on what players you’re looking at, but you’re going to get significantly better odds on first touchdown props than anytime touchdown props. For example, the Rams are opening the season by hosting the Bills on Thursday Night Football. Cooper Kupp has the shortest anytime touchdown odds at -160 on FanDuel Sportsbook, but that figure increases to +600 to score the first touchdown. In general, you can expect most of the top touchdown scorers in the league to be priced between +500 and +700 to score the first touchdown of the game.

Most of the other players who are expected to be on the field will likely be around +1000. Running backs will get plenty of love in this department – especially ones who tend to carry the ball near the goal line – followed by the rest of the receivers, tight ends, and quarterbacks.

Then comes the real long shots. The depth receivers, second straight tight ends, and non-rushing quarterbacks will all be priced at +2000 or greater. The less that a player is expected to be on the field, the greater the potential payout if they’re the first TD scorer.

How To Deal With The Swings

Betting on first touchdown scorer props is a lot like playing large tournaments in daily fantasy sports. Your win rate is going to be low, so you’re going to have to handle going through stretches with no wins. That can be demoralizing for bettors.

The key is to maximize your upside when you win. That allows you to survive the downswings and preserve your bankroll. If you’re upping your bets every time you hit a first touchdown prop, you’re not going to be able to survive the inevitable cold streaks. Like most things in life, discipline is key.

First TD Scorer Strategy

Just like with anytime touchdown scorer props, there is no surefire way to guarantee a win on first touchdown scorer props. That said, there are some things you can do to greatly increase your win rate.

Pay Attention To Injuries

Simply being on top of the injury report is one of the easiest ways to get value as a bettor. By knowing which players are questionable, you can often pounce on lines before the sportsbook has a chance to react.

For example, if the starting running back is questionable, I like to have some bets queued up on the backup running back. If he’s ultimately ruled out, you can potentially beat the sportsbook for tons of closing line value.

It’s not a fool-proof method, and the sportsbooks aren’t dumb. However, there are at least a few times a year when unexpected news leaves them open. Make sure you’re plugged into the news – Twitter alerts for the top news reporters are the best source – and take advantage when you can.

Defense (& Coaching) Matters

One of the most annoying things about betting on first-scorer props is that you are occasionally powerless. Only one team gets the first possession of each game, which means there’s a roughly 50/50 chance that your chosen player will start the game on the sidelines. If the opposing team goes down the field and scores, your player will have zero chance of scoring the first TD.

That’s why backing a player with a solid defense makes sense. If they can keep the opposing offense out of the end zone, it creates more chances for your player to score the first touchdown.

Additionally, knowing which coaches like to receive the ball after winning the coin toss is another way to create some value. The vast majority of coaches choose to defer at this point, but new coaches enter the league every year. Finding one who prefers to receive the ball almost guarantees they’re going to start the game on offense, which is a huge boost for first touchdown props.

Know The Goal Line Stats

Not all red zone touches are created equal. For running backs, in particular, getting the ball inside the five-yard line is a great way to rack up plenty of touchdowns.

There are some ways to exploit this. Last year, Boston Scott was the most profitable anytime TD scorer in the entire league. He had just 20 red zone touches, which put him well behind most of the top runners in the league. However, 16 of those attempts came from inside the 10-yard line, and 12 came from inside the five. Ultimately, only 10 running backs had more carries from inside the five-yard line than Scott last season.

I’m not sure who this year’s version of Scott will be, but staying on top of the numbers can help you turn a profit.

For more on how to bet on the NFL, check out some of the resources from the Betting 101 library: