Here at Props.com, our analysts spent countless hours in the lab to uncover the best Super Bowl Prop Bets. A gallon of coffee and hundreds of props later, our team successfully pinpointed the 18 best props for Super Bowl 57 between the Eagles and Chiefs.
Super Bowl Prop Bets 2023
Each analyst was asked to answer the following question regarding Super Bowl props. None of the writers were allowed to see what their colleagues selected. This created a few consensus prop bets without any conflicting advice. More than one analyst selected the following props:
- Eagles RB Miles Sanders Over 61.5 Rushing Yards
- Jersey Number Of First Touchdown Scorer: Over 11.5
Also, it seems like our analysts are predicting a high-scoring battle, as three props revolve around the overall total or team total going over the listed number.
With that, let’s take a look at the top overall Super Bowl Props on the board!
What Is Your Favorite Super Bowl Player Prop?
Patrick Mahomes Over 0.5 Interceptions (-105)
Analyst: Matt LaMarca
Mahomes has yet to throw an interception during the postseason, but this matchup is going to represent a steep step up in weight class. The Eagles have the best pass defense in the league, and they generated 17 interceptions during the regular season. They had a pick in their first postseason contest, but they didn’t have many opportunities against a QB-less 49ers’ squad in their second game. Mahomes is not known for his ball security – he threw 12 interceptions during the regular season – so I think the Eagles have a good chance for a takeaway in this spot.
Harrison Butker Over 2.5 Made Extra Points (-130)
Analyst: Spencer Limbach
Hear me out on this! The Chiefs are -170 to -175 at most sportsbooks to score more than 2.5 touchdowns. However, Butker is only -130 to make more than 2.5 extra points. That’s a pretty significant discount! Yes, we have to worry about a missed PAT or the Chiefs going for two. I’m willing to accept that risk, as there’s still a decent chance that Kansas City scores four touchdowns and gives Butker an extra attempt if something happens on the first three.
Butker is 93% on extra points this season, and he has made more than 2.5 PATs in eight of his last 11 games.
Jalen Hurts Over 1.5 Passing Touchdowns (+102)
Analyst: Justin Bales
The odds are relatively shocking. Hurts ended the season with 2+ passing touchdowns in 7 of his last 10 games. He also posted 2 touchdowns against the New York Giants in the Divisional Round.
The Kansas City Chiefs are giving up a league-high 1.9 passing touchdowns per game this season. I’m expecting the Philadelphia Eagles to be down at some point in the second half, giving them more reason to throw the ball.
Miles Sanders Over 61.5 yards rushing (-110)
Analyst: Zayd Hussein
The secret to the Eagles’ success is their offensive line. Throughout the season, the Philadelphia Eagles have been able to dominate the line of scrimmage. This is a line that opened around 54.5 and has been bet up all the way to 61.5 if you were able to get in on it early kudos to you! I love Miles Sanders in this spot, and I think the Eagles look to establish him early and often in the Super Bowl. Sanders has rushed for 132 yards in two total games this postseason. Look for him to continue rolling in the big game on Sunday!
Jody Fortson First Touchdown (+6000)
Analyst: Josh Shepardson
I discussed three player props for the Chiefs and for the Eagles earlier this week. Yet, I always love having a longshot bet on the Super Bowl as a recreational gambler with a limited bankroll. It’s fun having a small wager that has a chance at a substantial payout, namely when it’s not an outrageous bet.
First, the Chiefs are more likely to reach paydirt through the air than on the ground. In the regular season, Patrick Mahomes threw 41 touchdowns, and the Chiefs scored a more modest 18 times on the ground. Second, Jody Fortson scored two touchdowns in 13 games in the regular season and had a meaningful role in the scoring area. According to FantasyPros, Fortson was targeted five times inside the 10-yard line, with three of those looks coming inside the five-yard line. So, let’s hop on board Fortson’s long odds to be the first to reach paydirt in the Super Bowl.
First Touchdown Scorer Props – Who Will Score First TD Tonight? (Super Bowl 57)
Miles Sanders Over 59.5 Rushing Yards (-125)
Analyst: John Supowitz
Sanders had a career year with his first 1,000-yard season and setting career-highs with 11 touchdowns and 74.6 rushing yards per game. A critical part of his fantastic season is due to running behind one of the better offensive lines in the league that is filled with Pro Bowlers.
The Chiefs were an excellent rushing defense allowing the eight fewest rush yards per game. They did allow 4.4 yards per rush, and in the battle of trenches, the Eagles have the advantage. This will help Sanders go over.
What Is Your Favorite ‘Fun’ Super Bowl Prop Bet?
Halftime Guest Appearance: Jay-Z (-200)
Analyst: Spencer Limbach
You know Rihanna will have a few guests in her Super Bowl Halftime Show, and it would be an absolute missed opportunity if she didn’t have Jay-Z come out for at least one song. It could be during Umbrella or Run This Town, but bringing out the legend himself would unmistakably elevate the performance.
- Interested in more of these props? Check out our full article: Super Bowl Halftime Props
In fact, Apple Music released a trailer for the Halftime Show that featured Run This Town by Rihanna and Jay-Z. Do you mean to tell me that song won’t be on the setlist? It absolutely will, and it marks a perfect chance to bring out Jay-Z for a minute or two. Put it all together, and the -200 odds on this seem short.
Rihanna Under 8.5 Songs Performed (-115)
Analyst: John Supowitz
The novelty props are what make the Super Bowl special. The color of the Gatorade, commercials, celebrities, it’s all possible. We’ll stick with another popular one, and that is the halftime show with Rihanna. She has a ton of songs to choose from, but how many will she get in?
The past 12 halftime shows averaged 8.99 songs performed. Dr. Dre/Snoop Dogg/Eminem/Kendrick Lamar did 10, The Weeknd was on the lower side with seven, and Jennifer Lopez and Shakira had a whopping 15.
When it’s multiple billed performers, this number tends to be higher. While Rihanna should have special guests, I like the under.
Super Bowl Halftime Prop Bets 2023: First Song, Guest Appearance & More
Jersey Number of 1st TD Scorer Over 11.5 (+105)
Analyst: Josh Shepardson
This line feels like it’s off. Sure, there are players with jersey numbers under 11.5 who could score the first touchdown. Specifically, Jalen Hurts, A.J. Brown, DeVonta Smith, Isaiah Pacheco, Jerick McKinnon, JuJu Smith-Schuster, and Marquez Valdes-Scantling are all candidates. However, Patrick Mahomes, Travis Kelce, Dallas Goedert, all of the other tight ends on both teams, all of Philadelphia’s running backs, dark horses such as Justin Watson, Skyy Moore, and Quez Watkins, and most of the defensive players who could produce a pick-six or scoop-and-score have jersey numbers north of 11.5.
So, at plus money, I’ll gladly take the over. Further, there’s contingency value in this bet for gamblers taking advantage of sign-up and deposit bonuses that require a play through to cashout your winnings. This bet will hit early, allowing gamblers to work through their playthrough requirement faster.
Number of 1st TD Scorer: Over 11.5 (+105)
Analyst: Justin Bales
This comes down to which team you believe will score the first touchdown of the game. If it’s the Philadelphia Eagles, you likely take the under. You’re getting Jalen Hurts (rushing), AJ Brown, and Devonta Smith. If it’s the Chiefs, you’re getting Travis Kelce, Kadarius Toney, and others.
There are three players with +700 odds to score the first touchdown. Hurts, Kelce, and Miles Sanders. Two of the three have numbers above 11.5, and I believe there’s value in the over here.
Super Bowl MVP Speech: Thanks God First (+130)
Analyst: Zayd Hussein
Who will the MVP of Superbowl LVII thank first? The choices for this prop are as follows:
- Teammates -135
- God +150
- City +900
- Family +1200
- Coach +1500
- Owner +3000
- None of the above +1600.
For me, it’s between two options: ‘Teammates’ at -135 and ‘God’ at +150. Listen, we all know that pro athletes love to give credit where credit is due, and in this case, it’s all about thanking God for their victories. You hear it all the time in post-game interviews, with players starting off by saying, “First off, I want to thank God.” And get this, both of the starting QBs who are top contenders for MVP have said this after big, clutch games.
- For more crazy novelty props, check out Zayd’s full article: Fun Super Bowl Prop Bets
Just last week, Patrick Mahomes gave thanks to God after leading the Kansas City Chiefs to a win against Cincinnati. Can you believe that we can get odds of +150 on this happening? That’s crazy value if you ask me. So, mark my words, if either of these QBs wins, you can bet your bottom dollar that they’ll be giving thanks to God first and foremost!
Fun Super Bowl Prop Bets: Four Crazy Novelty Props For Super Bowl 57
Jersey Number of 1st Touchdown Scorer: Over 11.5 (+105)
Analyst: Matt LaMarca
I always enjoy these props. Essentially, taking the over on the jersey number of the first scorer gives you Travis Kelce, Miles Sanders, Patrick Mahomes, and Kadarius Toney, as well as some of the more peripheral options. There are more viable first-touchdown scorers with the under, but the over is available at better than even money and gives you the top two touchdown threats overall: Kelce and Sanders.
Kelce has scored the first touchdown in each of the Chiefs’ first two playoff games, and he led all players in Pro Football Focus expected touchdowns during the regular season. Sanders had the Eagles’ first touchdown in the NFC Championship, and his 11 touchdowns ranked second on the team during the regular season. I am a firm believer in quality over quantity, so I’m happy to take the over at plus-money.
What Is Your Favorite Game Or Team Prop?
Eagles Over 3.0 Sacks (+145)
Analyst: Matt LaMarca
This Eagles’ defense is an absolute monster. The 49ers got most of the attention this season in the “best defense in the league” department, but the Eagles were absolutely ferocious. They boast one of the best trios of cornerbacks in the league, and they supplement that with an elite pass rush. They were first in the league in adjusted sack rate, and they generated 70 sacks during the regular season. No other team had more than 55, so they were first in the league by a pretty wide margin.
Patrick Mahomes is still dealing with an ankle injury, and while he is reportedly feeling a lot better, he was pretty hampered against the Bengals. That’s not a good formula against this defense. The Eagles had five sacks in their first playoff contest and followed that up with three sacks against the 49ers. San Francisco barely attempted a pass in the second half, so this number shouldn’t be available at +145.
Kansas City Wins By 1-13 Points (+165)
Analyst: Spencer Limbach
I have fallen in love with winning margin props this season, especially in the playoffs. FanDuel Sportsbook offers the best lines on this bet type. You can find it by clicking on the “Super Bowl LVII tab” and then scrolling down to “More Wagers” under the Chiefs-Eagles games. It’s past the player props and titled “Winning Margin (4-Way)”.
So who will win this game? Opinions seem to be split in the betting community. However, most people believe this is going to be a close game that comes down to the last few possessions. If you subscribe to that notion, then betting on the winning margin may be of interest to you.
Personally, I see Kansas City winning a close one. Instead of taking the Chiefs moneyline at +104 odds, I’m looking for a healthier payout of +165. In order for my bet to be a winner, Kansas City needs to win this game, but not by more than 13 points. If you believe the Eagles will win a close game, you can bet “Philadelphia Wins By 1-13 Points” for nice +155 odds.
3 Best Chiefs Player Props For Super Bowl 57: Kelce’s Perfect Storm?
Game Total Over 50.5 Points (-110)
Analyst: Zayd Hussein
Listen up folks, buckle up for an explosive Superbowl showdown! This game is going to be a thrill ride with non-stop action and a high-scoring affair. The offenses are simply too potent and dynamic for the defenses to handle. Get ready to witness the brilliance of Patrick “Showtime” Mahomes as he takes the stage and lights up the scoreboards. And don’t count out the Eagles and the electrifying Jalen Hurts. They’re going to bring their A-game and keep the scoring going.
This game is going to soar over the posted total of 50.5 points. Take the over and head straight to the cashier window after the game to collect your winnings!
Kansas City Chiefs Over 24.5 Total Points (-112)
Analyst: Justin Bales
Patrick Mahomes has always found success in the postseason. He’s averaging 31.2 points per game as a starter in the playoffs. He’s posted 25+ points in 9 of his 14 starts. He also has missed with 22, 23, and 24 points.
I respect the Philadelphia Eagles defense, but when have they faced someone like Mahomes? They allowed 32 points to the Detroit Lions, Washington Commanders, Green Bay Packers, and Dallas Cowboys this season.
Kansas City Over 2.5 Touchdowns (-170)
Analyst: Josh Shepardson
The Chiefs had fewer than 2.5 touchdowns only five times this season when including their playoff contests. Meanwhile, the Eagles didn’t have a challenging schedule this year. However, talented offenses such as the Lions, Cowboys, and Packers each scored more than 2.5 touchdowns against Philly’s talented defense.
Mahomes and Co. are fully capable of reaching paydirt at least three times against the Eagles.
3 Best Eagles Player Props For Super Bowl 57: Run With Hurts?
First Quarter Over 9.5 Total Points (-130)
Analyst: John Supowitz
We have two of the better offenses this season, as both finished top five in points scored and top seven in total yards. Hurts and Mahomes will be in the running for regular season MVP, and their complement of weapons will give them the ability to move the ball on the ground and the air.
I have no doubt we will see scoring very early in this game, and betting over the first quarter total feels like a safe wager. All you need for the first quarter is a field goal and a touchdown to hit, and at worst, we’ll see that.
Is There An Odds Boost Or Sportsbook Bonus That Catches Your Eye?
FanDuel $3,000 No-Sweat First Bet
Analyst: Matt LaMarca
The best promotion in the industry right now is the $3,000 No-Sweat First Bet on FanDuel. You need to deposit $3,000 to take full advantage, but essentially, you can get your first bet refunded to you as site credits if it loses.
- More Bonus Offers: Check out our complete list of Super Bowl Sportsbook Bonus Offers.
For example, if you bet $3,000 on the Eagles – my preferred side for the Super Bowl – and they don’t cover, you’ll get $3,000 refunded to you in free bets. If you don’t have $3,000 to throw around, fear not. You can still utilize this promotion for whatever amount you feel comfortable depositing, be it $10 or $3,000.
Underdog Fantasy Big Game Promo: Jalen Hurts “Free Square”
Analyst: Spencer Limbach
Underdog presents a special Pick’em for the Big Game: Jalen Hurts Higher or Lower than 0.5 Total Yards (max $20)
Take Hurts Over 0.5 Yards and pick up the easy win if the Eagles’ star QB manages at least one total yard on Sunday. You need to pair this with another prop to 3x your payout, so it’s a good thing we listed all those player props earlier in the article.
If you are new to Underdog Fantasy, here’s how to get started and redeem this promotion:
- Sign-up for Underdog Fantasy using the banner below.
- Enter promo code PROPS and receive up to a $100 despoit match.
- Use that free money to place up to $20 on Jalen Hurts over 0.5 Yards and one other player prop.
- Turn $20 into $60 if your player prop parlay wins.
FanDuel No Sweat Same Game Parlay: 3+ Legs With +400 Odds Or Longer
Analyst: Josh Shepardson
This isn’t an actual boost, but it fits the spirit of the question. Many of the promotions throughout the betting world are for new customers. Fortunately, the no-sweat SGP at FanDuel Sportsbook is available to new and existing customers. Moreover, a max $5 wager appeals to even small-stakes and recreational gamblers.
And, of course, there’s the possibility of hitting the SGP and collecting the winnings, too. Even if you don’t gamble on other sports, the $5 betting credit can be used on NFL futures for 2023. So, gamblers shouldn’t sweat the time limit on the free play.
From the FanDuel Sportsbook main lobby, click on the “Promotions” tab to see the terms and conditions of the offer and opt-in for the bonus.
Check out our Guide to Same Game Parlays for more on how SGP bets work.
DraftKings Same Game Parlay Boost
Analyst: John Supowitz
DraftKings has a good SGP boost that could inspire a big payout if you strike the right combination. If you look at the terms, it says the more legs you add to the parlay, the bigger the boost (EX: 3 Legs: 20% Boost, 4 Legs: 25% Boost…).
I’ve already given you the Miles Sanders prop and the over. For the third leg, I’m adding a Travis Kelce anytime touchdown. Then, if you feel confident about more legs, keep it going.
Travis Kelce & AJ Brown 50+ Receiving Yards Each (+100)
Analyst: Justin Bales
This shouldn’t come as a surprise. The Super Bowl is where the best players come to play. Kelce is the best tight end in the NFL, and Brown is proving that the Tennessee Titans made a terrible mistake trading him.
This is a great matchup for Brown, as the Kansas City Chiefs have struggled against outside receivers. It isn’t as good of a matchup for Kelce, but he’s about as matchup-proof of a player as there is in the NFL, specifically at this low of a number.
You can grab this as a same-game parlay boost at DraftKings Sportsbook (see above).
More Super Bowl Prop Bets 2023
NFL Anytime Touchdown Scorer Predictions & Best Bets (Super Bowl 57)
Super Bowl Gatorade Color Prop Bet: Odds & Prediction For Super Bowl 57
