NHL Props Thursday: Wingers Jake Guentzel, Tyler Toffoli Poised to Score

look on Pittsburgh Penguins left wing Jake Guentzel (59) during the Pittsburgh Penguins versus the Montreal Canadiens game on November 18, 2021, at Bell Centre in Montreal, QC
Image Credit: David Kirouac/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Without even considering NHL Props, it’s already been a crazy week in the league. The Canadiens hired Martin St. Louis to replace Dominique Ducharme as head coach, veteran goalie Tuukka Rask has called it a career, and world-class irritant Brad Marchand earned a six-game suspension with some serious bush-league behavior.

All that, and we haven’t even reached Thursday’s slate of games!

Let’s dive into five intriguing NHL Props for Thursday’s robust seven-game slate.

All odds via DraftKings and updated as of 2 p.m. ET on Feb. 10.

Pittsburgh Penguins: LW Jake Guentzel

Jake Guentzel #59 of the Pittsburgh Penguins skates against the St. Louis Blues at PPG PAINTS Arena on January 5, 2022 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Image Credit: Joe Sargent/NHLI via Getty Images

The Prop: Score Anytime Goal (at Ottawa)
The Odds: -105

Guentzel has been on a tear this season, ranking 12th in goals with 23 and vastly exceeding a point-per-game pace (48 points in 41 contests).

He showed the hockey world just how lethal his shot is during All-Star weekend in Las Vegas, finishing second in the accuracy challenge. And now here’s the sweet part for Thursday’s NHL props bettors: 16 of Guentzel’s goals have come on the road.

While his otherworldly 23.5 percent shooting rate in road-only games isn’t exactly sustainable, it could hold up tonight. That’s because the Penguins need to lean on Guentzel to provide an offensive spark with fellow scorers Evgeni Malkin (COVID-19 protocols) and Jason Zucker (core muscle surgery) on the shelf.

Ottawa yields 3.31 goals per game, 11th in the league, but they also allow the sixth-most shots per game at 33.6. As a team, Pittsburgh scores the fourth-most goals per road game at 3.39.

Guentzel had an assist earlier in the season at Ottawa, then lit the lamp against the Sens in a home game on Jan. 20. That gave him eight goals in nine career games versus Ottawa. Make it nine goals in 10 games tonight!

Montreal Canadiens: RW Tyler Toffoli

Tyler Toffoli #73 of the Montreal Canadiens skates for position against the Anaheim Ducks in the NHL game at the Bell Centre on January 27, 2022 in Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Image Credit: Francois Lacasse/NHLI via Getty Images

The Prop: Score Anytime Goal (vs. Washington)
The Odds: +200

The Montreal Canadiens are the only team in the NHL without a 10-goal scorer on their roster. That’s going to change Thursday night, courtesy of Toffoli.

The 29-year-old center is starting to heat up, with goals in two of his last three, and three or more shots in eight of his last nine games (four total goals in that stretch). His shooting percentage is down nearly 50 percent compared with 2020-21 (9.8% this year, career-best 17.8% last year). But we know what kind of a potent scorer Toffoli can be, so expect that percentage to rise the rest of the way.

With a new head coach behind the bench beginning Wednesday, it’s possible Toffoli will get an extra boost as systems and linemates may change.

This is also a favorable matchup for Toffoli, because Washington is in a tough spot. The Capitals will be without Alex Ovechkin, Vitek Vanecek, and T.J. Oshie. That’s some serious lost firepower.

Ilya Samsonov is the likely starter in net for the Caps, but his .902 save percentage and 2.89 GAA don’t inspire a ton of confidence. Nor does this factoid: Washington has allowed three goals or more in four of its last five games.

Editor’s Note: New to NHL props? Check out our complete NHL Props Betting Guide to get up to speed!

Columbus Blue Jackets: RW Patrik Laine

Patrik Laine #29 of the Columbus Blue Jackets skates during the third period of a game against the Pittsburgh Penguins at Nationwide Arena on January 21, 2022 in Columbus, Ohio.
Image Credit: Ben Jackson/NHLI via Getty Images

The Prop: 2.5 Total Shots (at Buffalo)
The Odds: Over -115/Under -115

With six goals in his last three games, Patrik Laine is looking like the 40-goal scorer he was back when he donned a Winnipeg Jets sweater. He’s now tied for second on the team in goals despite playing nearly 20 fewer games than those with whom he’s tied.

Columbus’ offense is coming to life around him as well, tallying four goals or more in each of its past four games. The Blue Jackets are even 3-1 during this stretch (an 8-4 loss to Florida being the lone blemish).

Laine is averaging 2.72 shots per game this season, and he’s put at least three pucks on net in four of his last five contests (including three in a row). He’s also registered exactly five shots in each of his last three road games.

Meanwhile, Buffalo allows the second-most shots per game at 34.9, which bodes well for Laine’s chances to beat this prop. As does this: He’s tallied 21 shots in eight career games against the Sabres (2.63 per game).

St. Louis Blues: C Jordan Kyrou

Jordan Kyrou #25 of the St. Louis Blues in action against the Los Angeles Kings at the Enterprise Center on October 25, 2021 in St. Louis, Missouri.
Image Credit: Scott Rovak/NHLI via Getty Images

The Prop: Score Anytime Goal (vs. New Jersey)
The Odds: +185

Fresh off his first All-Star Game appearance and a win in the fastest skater competition, Kyrou returns from the break as St. Louis’ leading goal scorer. He also ranks third on the team in shots. However, he’s tied for the fourth-best odds among Blues skaters as an anytime goal-scorer in Thursday’s home match against the Devils.

With three goals in his last five games, Kyrou should stay hot against a Devils team that’s allowed the fourth-most goals per game this season (3.49 overall, 3.78 on the road). New Jersey netminders also sport an .886 save percentage, third-worst in the league.

Yes, the Devils held down the Canadiens in Tuesday’s 7-1 victory. But prior to that, New Jersey had surrendered 17 goals in three games and four goals or more in seven of 11 contests.

Toronto Maple Leafs: C John Tavares

John Tavares #91 of the Toronto Maple Leafs skates during the game against the New Jersey Devils on February 1, 2022 at the Prudential Center in Newark, New Jersey.
Image Credit: Rich Graessle/Getty Images

The Prop: 0.5 Total Assists (at Calgary)
The Odds: Over +125/Under -155

Coming off Monday’s two-assist game against the Carolina Hurricanes, Tavares is in a great position to get into the assist column against Calgary on Thursday. He’s tied for second on the team with 25 helpers in 42 games this season, and is second among forwards in power-play time on ice. So the opportunities figure to be there.

Tavares has posted eight multi-point games this season. He’s then proceeded to tally an assist after a multi-point game six times.

Calgary is riding high off Wednesday’s 6-0 beatdown of the Vegas Golden Knights, and the Flames are 4-1-1 this season during the second leg of a back-to-back. Still, the Maple Leafs are on a six-game win streak, and they’ve poured in a whopping 40 goals in their last eight contests.

Admittedly, Tavares has struggled in the assist department on the road, with just 10 in 20 games (and only four in his last 11 roadies). But he’s got a hot hand right now, so let’s ride it.