MLB All-Star Game Predictions: Can AL Make It 10 Straight?

May 23, 2023; Bronx, New York, USA; New York Yankees pitcher Gerrit Cole (45) delivers a pitch against the Baltimore Orioles during the first inning at Yankee Stadium.
Image Credit: Gregory Fisher-USA TODAY Sports

The MLB All-Star Game 2023 is slated for Tuesday, July 11 at the iconic T-Mobile Park in Seattle. The air is thick with anticipation as the American League and National League prepare for an intense battle.

How will this one play out? Let’s dive into the MLB All-Star Game predictions, odds, and picks below.

MLB All-Star Game Odds

  • Moneyline: American League -115 / National League -105 
  • Total: 7.5

Odds via Bet365. If you are new to Bet365, click our exclusive promo link below to Bet $1 to Get $200 in bonus bets, regardless if you win or lose.

Also, Bet365 released a cool promotion for this MLB season: If the team you bet on gains a 5-run advantage (at any time), your moneyline bet will be paid out.

Game Info

  • Date: Tuesday, July 11
  • Time: 8 pm ET
  • Location: T-Mobile Park – Seattle, WA
  • TV: FOX

MLB All-Star Game Betting Trends

  • American League is 47-43-2 vs. National League
  • Total has gone Under in last 12 of 16 All-Star Games

Wondering if MLB betting is available in your state? Check out our guide to the Best MLB Betting Sites.

MLB All-Star Game Predictions

With a 47-43-2 record against the National League, the American League is riding the wave of a 9-game winning streak. The sportsbook odds, however, suggest a nail-bitingly close match, with the National League at -105 underdogs and the American League at -115 favorites.

The over/under is set at 7.5 runs, reflecting the trend of the total falling under in 12 of the last 16 All-Star Games.

Over the years, the American League has asserted its dominance in the All-Star Game, securing 26 of the last 32 matchups. This supremacy is mirrored in the sportsbook odds, despite the National League boasting a more potent batting lineup this year.

The American League, however, holds an edge with its formidable pitching roster, spearheaded by the likes of Gerrit Cole, Luis Castillo, and Kevin Gausman.

Team lineups also have a significant influence on the game’s outcome. The Texas Rangers and Atlanta Braves are at the forefront with the highest number of All-Stars in the American League and National League respectively. However, the American League’s batting lineup might feel the pinch due to the absence of big hitters like Mike Trout and Aaron Judge.

MLB All-Star Game Picks

Considering these factors, our prediction for the MLB All-Star Game 2023 leans toward the American League.

Despite the National League’s powerful batting lineup, the American League’s superior pitching and historical dominance suggest a possible extension of their winning streak to 10 games.

The Pick: American League moneyline (-115) | Bet $1, Get $200 (win or lose) at Bet365