Best Underdog Fantasy Picks Today – 20x Your Stake (Updated)

May 8, 2024; New York, New York, USA; New York Knicks forward Precious Achiuwa (5) warms up prior to game two of the second round for the 2024 NBA playoffs against the Indiana Pacers at Madison Square Garden.
Image Credit: Wendell Cruz-USA TODAY Sports

Our Props analysts are on the lookout for the best Underdog Fantasy Picks today while unearthing these Underdog Fantasy pick’em gems to maximize your bankroll.

Check out our daily picks that could 20x your original stake when you pick 5 at Underdog Fantasy.

Why Underdog Fantasy?

Underdog Fantasy is available in 30+ states, regardless of whether that state has legalized sports betting or not. They also have a smooth app with plenty of player prop options across numerous sports.

If you are new, sign-up using promo code PROPS to receive up to a $100 deposit match.

Simply click the banner below and the promo code will populate!

Top Underdog Fantasy Pick’em Predictions & Cheat Sheet

The following table breaks down Underdog Fantasy pick’em predictions for the NBA on Saturday, April 20.

Player NamePropLineProjectionL10 OverL10 UnderPick
Josh HartThree Points Made0.51.282Over
Myles TurnerThree Points Made1.5373Over
Andrew NembhardRebounds1.52.8982Over
Josh HartBlocks0.50.9164Over
Jalen BrunsonSteals0.50.8746Over
Miles McBrideAssists3.51.237Under
Pascal SiakamSteals0.50.864Over
Pascal SiakamTurnovers1.50.628Under
Alec BurksPoints14.5628Under
Miles McBrideAssists2.51.237Under
Alec BurksThree Points Made2.51.219Under
Alec BurksPR14.57.837Under
Alec BurksPoints10.5637Under
Josh HartAssists3.54.9973Over
Alec BurksPA12.57.237Under
Tyrese HaliburtonThree Points Made2.53.5664Over
Josh HartSteals1.50.9537Under
Andrew NembhardAssists3.54.7791Over
Isaiah HartensteinBlocks1.50.9828Under
Andrew NembhardPR11.515.3582Over
T.J. McConnellRebounds3.52.3737Under
Miles McBridePA16.511.2437Under
Miles McBridePR16.511.3746Under
Jalen BrunsonAssists5.57.282Over
Andrew NembhardPoints9.512.4382Over
Myles TurnerSteals0.50.3546Under
Miles McBridePAR18.513.0237Under
Miles McBridePoints13.59.5737Under
Miles McBrideRebounds2.51.837Under
T.J. McConnellPoints12.5937Under
Andrew NembhardPA13.517.2791Over
Josh HartRebounds10.513.1973Over
Obi ToppinPA10.513.1673Over
Donte DiVincenzoRebounds3.54.3773Over
Pascal SiakamRebounds9.57.1719Under
Donte DiVincenzoThree Points Made2.53.0655Over
Andrew NembhardPAR16.520.1982Over
Jalen BrunsonRebounds4.53.5328Under
Isaiah HartensteinRebounds10.58.2528Under
Obi ToppinPoints9.511.5173Over
Isaiah HartensteinPoints8.510.2355Over
Alec BurksThree Points Made1.51.237Under
Andrew NembhardThree Points Made1.51.237Under
Myles TurnerTurnovers1.51.237Under
Myles TurnerSB2.5255Under
Precious AchiuwaTurnovers0.50.655Under
Andrew NembhardAssists44.7746Over
Isaiah HartensteinRA14.51228Under
Precious AchiuwaPR10.58.7137Under
Donte DiVincenzoAssists3.52.9146Under
Miles McBridePoints11.59.5746Under
Obi ToppinPR13.515.7182Over
Tyrese HaliburtonRebounds5.54.6446Under
Josh HartPoints14.516.6973Over
Myles TurnerRebounds7637Under
T.J. McConnellPoints10.5937Under
Donte DiVincenzoPoints19.516.846Under
Aaron NesmithPoints11.510.0446Under
Donte DiVincenzoRebounds54.3728Under
Pascal SiakamPoints21.518.8337Under
Myles TurnerPoints19.517.0855Under
Pascal SiakamPR29.525.9237Under
Josh HartPA19.521.7173Over
Isaiah HartensteinPA12.513.8755Over
Pascal SiakamRebounds87.1746Under
T.J. McConnellRA87.246Under
Tyrese HaliburtonAssists98.1437Under
Pascal SiakamPAR32.529.5128Under
Myles TurnerRebounds5.5655Over
Tyrese HaliburtonPoints20.518.6837Under
Tyrese HaliburtonPA29.526.9337Under
Tyrese HaliburtonAssists7.58.1455Over
Pascal SiakamPA24.522.4228Under
Josh HartPAR31.534.1373Over
Andrew NembhardPoints11.512.4364Over
T.J. McConnellPR13.512.4246Under
Aaron NesmithRebounds55.446Under
T.J. McConnellAssists55.446Under
Jalen BrunsonPA40.543.4564Over
Obi ToppinThree Points Made1.51.6164Under
Tyrese HaliburtonPoints17.518.6855Over
Miles McBrideThree Points Made1.51.664Under
Isaiah HartensteinAssists43.7437Under
Myles TurnerPR24.522.9255Under
Josh HartRA1718.0564Over
Josh HartPR27.529.1764Over
Isaiah HartensteinPAR23.522.0746Under
Aaron NesmithSteals0.50.5346Under
Obi ToppinTurnovers0.50.5355Under
Tyrese HaliburtonPAR33.531.5337Under
Tyrese HaliburtonRA13.512.7146Under
Aaron NesmithPA11.512.1655Over
Josh HartRebounds12.513.1964Over
Aaron NesmithPAR16.517.4173Over
Tyrese HaliburtonPR24.523.3255Under
Myles TurnerPAR26.525.2455Under
Donte DiVincenzoPR21.522.5155Over
T.J. McConnellThree Points Made0.50.4837Under
Josh HartPoints17.516.6964Under
Jalen BrunsonPAR4547.0264Over
Jalen BrunsonPoints34.535.9964Over
Myles TurnerPoints16.517.0855Over
Jalen BrunsonRA10.510.8764Over
Isaiah HartensteinPR1918.3846Under
Donte DiVincenzoPAR24.525.2955Over
Tyrese HaliburtonRebounds4.54.6446Under
Isaiah HartensteinRebounds8.58.2537Under
Jalen BrunsonPR38.539.5764Over
T.J. McConnellPAR18.51855Under
Pascal SiakamRA1110.7137Under
Pascal SiakamAssists3.53.5955Under
Myles TurnerRA8.58.3146Under
Donte DiVincenzoPA2020.455Over
Aaron NesmithPR1515.2773Over
Myles TurnerPA19.519.2755Under
Donte DiVincenzoPoints1716.855Under
Aaron NesmithThree Points Made1.51.5255Under
T.J. McConnellPA15.515.6155Over
Aaron NesmithPoints1010.0455Over
Obi ToppinPoints11.511.5173Over

Looking For Our Top Underdog Selections?

Check our Best NBA Parlays hub for PrizePicks, Underdog, and Sleeper Fantasy slips. It’s updated daily!

Best NBA Parlays Today – Top NBA Parlay Picks (Updated Daily)

Underdog Fantasy Payouts

Refer to the table below for the Underdog Fantasy payout structure on pick’em contests.

As you add more legs to an entry, the risk increases, and correspondingly, the potential payout is higher to compensate for that added risk.

Number of PicksStandard UpsideInsured UpsideInsured if One Wrong
Two3xN/AN/A
Three6x3x1x
Four10x6x1.5x
Five20x10x2.5x

As you’ll notice, there’s a significant difference between opting for insurance on Underdog Fantasy picks and going without it. Ultimately, the choice boils down to your level of confidence and your risk tolerance.

Underdog Fantasy Pick’em Insurance

In a standard contest, achieving a 5-for-5 performance will net you a 20x return on your initial investment.

On the other hand, the same feat in an insured contest will yield a 10x return—quite a notable difference.

However, insured contests have a safety net: if you go 4-for-5, you still earn a 2.5x payout.

In a standard contest, a 4-for-5 performance means you walk away with nothing. Whether this added safety is worth the reduced potential gains is a matter of your personal risk tolerance.

Refer to this link for a complete breakdown of how insurance works based on the Pick 5 structure at Underdog Fantasy.

More Apps Like Underdog Fantasy

Explore our comprehensive list of Apps Like Prizepicks and Underdog Fantasy to discover more bonus offers. These bonuses can give you extra credit for participating in props pick’em contests on other sites, such as Sleeper, Boom Fantasy, ParlayPlay, Chalkboard Fantasy, Dabble, and more.

All in all, you can claim up to $1,250 in bonus credit by signing up for these fantasy apps.