18 min read

Best NFL Player Prop Bets Today

Props Staff

Props Staff

Last updated: September 8, 2025

Christian McCaffrey is one of our best NFL props today.

In this article, our expert analysts outline their favorite NFL player props for every week of the season.

Below, you’ll see our top NFL player prop picks across different categories like yardage, touchdowns, interceptions, completions, attempts, and more. In other words, if there’s an NFL player prop with value, then you better believe we are going for it.

Best NFL player props today

Our analysts run through their favorite NFL player props for the major slates each week.

Here are our top plays for NFL Week 1 Thursday Night Football and Monday Night Football. Check back later this week for Sunday plays!

Tank bigsby lower than 44.5 rushing yards

The Jaguars’ backfield has the potential to be a nightmare all season.

They had already invested massive draft capital into the position, selecting Travis Etienne in the first round in 2021 and Bigsby in the third round in 2023, and they took another swing in 2025.

They added Bhayshul Tuten at the beginning of the fourth round, further complicating an already complicated situation.

Tuten is an intriguing prospect, and he only lasted as long as he did because of the depth at running back in this draft class. He blazed a 4.32 40-yard dash at the combine, putting him in the 100th percentile for the position.

He also ranks in the 98th percentile for Speed Score and 97th percentile for Burst Score, and he earned a9.56 Relative Athletic Score. Ultimately, he’s going to be a part of this equation.

That leaves Bigsby with an uncertain role. Etienne is tentatively penciled in as the team’s starter, leaving Bigsby to compete with Tuten for the remaining opportunities.

Bigsby is probably looking at close to a third of the team’s rushing attempts, with the most optimistic projections probably closer to 50%.

I personally have Bisgby projected for fewer than nine carries on Sunday, which means he’s going to have to be very efficient to get to 45 yards. I’m happy to go against him at this figure.

Where to play: Tank Bigsby Lower Than 44.5 Rushing Yards |Underdog

Christian mccaffrey lower than 16.5 rushing attempts

One of the biggest questions facing fantasy players this offseason was how to approach McCaffrey. He was considered one of the best players in football in previous seasons, but he missed nearly all of last year with an injury.

He also didn’t appear to be the same player when he was on the field, averaging just 4.0 yards-per-carry with zero scores in his four outings.

McCaffrey has reportedly looked close to his old self during training camp, which is great news for the 49ers. If they’re going to get back to being an elite offensive team, they’re going to need to get more production out of him.

That said, they still might want to be careful about overworking him. Specifically, they might not want to wear him down with too many carries between the 20s.

That makes a ton of sense, and it helps explain why the 49ers traded for Brian Robinson before the start of the year. Robinson is a prototypical between-the-tackles grinder, so he can help ease some of that burden on McCaffrey.

Even during McCaffrey’s elite 2023 season, he still had fewer than 16.5 carries in seven of 16 contests. Elijah Mitchell was there to help carry some of the load, and with McCaffrey now 29 years old, Robinson should fill that void this season.

That’s particularly true early in the year, with McCaffrey not having the benefit of any preseason opportunities. Add it all up, and this number feels a smidge too high.

Where to play: Christian McCaffrey Lower Than 16.5 Rushing Attempts | Underdog

Mark andrews higher than 44.5 receiving yards

Andrews has been a top receiving threat at tight end for the past half-decade, but he took a bit of a step back last season. He averaged just 39.6 receiving yards per game after sitting above 50 in each of the previous five seasons.

However, that number doesn’t quite tell the whole story. Andrews was basically invisible for the first handful of games last year, averaging just 16.3 receiving yards over his first four contests. That includes two games where he managed just one target and zero receptions.

After that, Andrews looked more like the player of old. He averaged closer to 47 yards over his final 13 regular-season outings, and he capped things off with 61 receiving yards in their playoff loss to the Bills.

Andrews will face those same Bills on Sunday, and the team could need him a bit more than usual. Part of the reason for Andrews’ decreased production has been the emergence of Isaiah Likely. However, Likely missed practice on Thursday, and his status for the season opener is in doubt. He is not expected to suit up for the time being, leaving Andrews as the clear No. 1 TE in Baltimore.

Ultimately, I expect this number to rise if/when Likely is ruled out. Let’s jump on it while we can.

Where to play: Mark Andrews Higher Than 44.5 Receiving Yards | Underdog

Justin jefferson anytime touchdown scorer

Justin Jefferson has only missed time in one of his five seasons, so he’s generally as durable as they come. Every year that Jefferson has been healthy, he’s posted at least 1,400 yards through the air and sometimes a lot more.

That level of consistency is rare even among elite wideouts and makes him a bankable weapon regardless of game flow or matchup.

His ability to create separation early in routes, win at the catch point, and finish through contact gives him scoring equity in every part of the field, not just inside the red-zone.

Whether it’s contested sideline fades, deep crossers off play-action, or back-shoulder timing routes, Jefferson executes at an elite level and demands constant defensive attention.

His Anytime Touchdown Scorer prop against the Bears offers real value at +120 when considering his role as the clear top option in a high-volume passing game.

His size, hands, and route polish make him difficult to eliminate from the game plan, even when bracketed or shadowed.

And with at least 1,400 yards in every healthy season, along with only one stretch of missed time across five full years, there’s no reason to treat him as anything but a top-tier red-zone finisher every time he steps on the field.

Pick:Justin Jefferson Anytime Touchdown Scorer

Caleb williams over 218.5 passing yards

In the 100+ year history of the Chicago Bears franchise, no quarterback has ever thrown for 4,000 yards. But this year, with a passing-oriented head coach and a stable of weapons in D.J. Moore, Rome Odunze, Luther Burden III, and Colston Loveland, this is Caleb Williams’ time.

I don’t think he played all that well last year and still threw for 3,541 yards. That alone speaks volumes about his natural yardage production, even when operating with inconsistency and limited efficiency.

Williams thrives when given vertical threats and space to improvise, and this group gives him dynamic targets at every layer.

Moore and Odunze can stretch and isolate coverage, Burden offers shiftiness and acceleration after the catch, and Loveland provides a soft-hands outlet underneath, all supporting Williams’ strengths as an instinctive thrower who doesn’t need a perfect pocket to deliver.

Over 218.5 passing yards at -114, matches up well with what he’s already proven: that he can produce volume without playing clean. Hitting 3,541 yards in a season where performance lagged shows that he doesn’t need elite execution to reach solid passing totals.

In a system now built to showcase his arm and decision-making, and with four legitimate weapons spacing the field, this total becomes more about opportunity than perfection, and 218.5 against the Vikings sits well within reach.

Pick:Caleb WilliamsOver 218.5 Passing Yards

Where to place NFL player prop bets

The best sportsbooks for NFL player prop betting are FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM, Caesars, bet365, and Fanatics. You’ll find large prop menus, solid Same-Game Parlay (SGP) tools, live betting, regular promos, and simple, easy to use apps. The mix varies by book.

FanDuel and DraftKings stand out for the number of props and easy SGP builders. BetMGM is reliable for competitive odds and a strong rewards program. Caesars posts deep markets, including novelty options, and bet365 is strong in live betting.

Newer books like Fanatics are building comprehensive prop offerings too, so you have plenty of places to compare odds.

New Players Only, Must be 21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Must be Present in Legal State. Full T&Cs Apply. Please Play Responsibly. See more…
Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (Available in the US). Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), Call 1-800-327-5050 (MA), 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 1-800-981-0023 (PR). 21+ only. Please Gamble Responsibly. See BetMGM.com for Terms. First Bet Offer for new customers only (if applicable). Subject to eligibility requirements. Bonus bets are non-withdrawable. In partnership with Kansas Crossing Casino and Hotel. This promotional offer is not available in DC, Mississippi, New York, Nevada, Ontario, or Puerto Rico. See more…
Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (Available in the US) Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY) Call 1-800-327-5050 (MA), 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA). 21+ only. Please Gamble Responsibly. Terms and conditions apply. Subject to eligibility requirements. Bonus bets are non-withdrawable. This promotional offer is not available in Mississippi, Nevada, Ontario, or Puerto Rico. See more…

What are the available stat-based NFL player props?

Stat-based NFL player props focus on individual stat lines for a single game, no matter the position. Most are set as over or under on a posted number. Unlike positional markets, you judge projected volume, efficiency, and matchup strength to decide whether a player goes over the line or under it.

Here are the main categories on offer, and how to approach each one without overcomplicating it.

Touchdowns (anytime, first, OR last)

Touchdown scorer markets come in a few different versions with different levels of risk and reward. They are popular because the bet is easy to understand, and the payouts can be high.

Anytime touchdown props ask a simple question, will a player score at least one touchdown at any point in the game. First touchdown props pay if your pick scores the game’s first TD, while last touchdown props grade the final scorer. The odds stretch as the prediction gets harder. Picking the exact first or last scorer is tougher than anytime, so the price is bigger.

These bets are about opportunity, and usage near the goal line is the clearest sign. Players who consistently touch the ball inside the 10-yard line (targets or carries) are more likely to score a touchdown. Watch how a team calls plays near the goal line to see who gets the ball.

Team scoring outlook matters too. A player on a high-powered offense projected around 28 or more points will see more chances than someone on a team expected to score fewer than 20. More points usually means more touchdown chances.

Player role is the next filter. A running back who handles most goal line carries is a safer anytime TD bet than a receiver sharing red zone targets with two teammates. You are buying touches as much as talent.

Touchdown props have more variance than yardage or receptions, but the payouts often compensate. If you stick to dependable near goal line roles, the anytime market can be a good hunting ground for value. First and last TD bets are more volatile because the odds are higher, which reflects the added unpredictability. Consider smaller stakes for those.

Total yards (passing, rushing, receiving)

Total yardage props are among the most common stat-based bets. For quarterbacks, you are betting passing yards, for running backs and receivers, it is rushing yards or receiving yards. Your job is to decide whether a player will exceed or fall short of a specific yardage threshold.

Start with usage and efficiency. How many attempts or touches is the player likely to get, and what do they usually gain per attempt. A back who sees about 20 carries and averages 4.5 yards per carry has a higher floor than one projected for 12 carries, even if their per carry efficiency looks similar, because volume evens out some of the variance.

Pace of play affects these numbers. Faster offenses create more snaps, which means more chances to gain yards. Teams like the Ravens or Chiefs that run more offensive plays per game tend to support overs, while slower groups like the Browns or Panthers limit opportunities. Ask whether this game will produce enough plays to support the posted number.

The matchup is key. Check what the opposing defense allows per play in the relevant category. A quarterback facing a defense giving up 7.5 yards per attempt is more likely to clear a passing number than one facing a 6.0 yard unit. That single detail can move you from pass to play.

For example, a quarterback in a high tempo offense against a soft pass defense is a better candidate to beat a 280.5 yard prop than a runner with limited projected carries against a strong run front. If the pace is low, the defense is tough, and volume is capped, the under makes more sense.

Receptions, carries, OR completions

These are often called volume props, because you are betting how often a player is involved, not how many yards they gain per touch. If you prefer role clarity over big plays, these props fit.

Role and volume come first. Running backs with defined pass catching jobs see higher reception lines, while a quarterback’s completions reflect expected pass rate and game script. A receiver who reliably earns 10+ targets per game will sit higher than one in the 5–6 target range, because opportunity is built into the price.

Scheme and matchup shape the ceiling. Some defenses allow easy completions in zone coverage, which can boost reception and completion props, while others tighten windows, force runs, or increase incompletions. If you know the likely coverage, your bet gets clearer.

Down and distance tendencies are the tiebreaker. Who gets the ball on early downs. Who plays third downs. A third down specialist might play fewer total snaps but still clear a reception number because that role funnels targets when it matters.

Tie it all to expected play calling and game flow. Teams run more with a lead and pass more when trailing, so your over or under call should match likely coaching tendencies. When your projection matches how a team usually plays, you are aligning with usage, not guessing.

What are the possible positional NFL player props?

Positional props tie to where a player lines up and their typical role. If you know how a role turns into touches and chances, you can judge the lines instead of guessing. Team tendencies, player usage, and coaching choices shape the price, so your edge often comes from knowing how a team plans to play, not just the depth chart.

Here are the main positional NFL player props and what affects them.

Quarterback props

Quarterback markets center on passing yards, completions, touchdowns, and interceptions, with game script often in control.

Here is how a yardage line works. If Joe Burrow’s passing yards prop is 257.5, you are choosing whether he throws for more or fewer than that number. The over wins at 260, the under wins at 250. Simple, though not easy, because you need to consider many things that can affect your these bets success rate.

If a team trails, you usually see more dropbacks and higher passing counts. If it is protecting a lead, the calls lean run heavy, which caps QB volume.

The matchup matters! Weak pass defenses or weak pass rushes can improve efficiency, while pass-first, fast-tempo teams increase total chances. Weather is another factor. Wind and steady rain lower deep passing success, so unders can look better in these circumstances.

Running back props

Running back props cover rushing attempts, rushing yards, receptions, and total scrimmage yards (rushing + receiving).

As an example, if Rhamondre Stevenson’s rushing line is 56.5 and he finishes with 60 yards, the over wins. At 50 yards, the under does.

Two pillars drive these bets. Volume and efficiency. How many carries is the back likely to get, and what does he average per attempt. Some players, Christian McCaffrey is a clear example, add meaningful receiving work, which makes combo props appealing because you are capturing more than one path to production.

The offensive line and the opposing run defense set the base, and game flow does the rest. Teams protecting a lead run more, teams chasing points pass more and run less.

Red-zone usage is a key tiebreaker. Backs who handle goal-line snaps gain touchdown chances and short-yardage volume.

Wide receiver and tight end props

Receiver and tight end props focus on receptions, receiving yards, longest catch, and sometimes air yards.

Start with target share, the slice of team attempts a player gets, because steady 25–30% targets create both floor and ceiling, while a 10–15% role adds variance.

Quarterback quality affects these markets, and strong coverage can lower a line while soft zones create openings.

Route depth and air yards matter for longest-catch and yardage bets. Deep threats vary a lot week to week, but one deep catch can clear the number.

Red-zone targets also matter. Repeat looks near the goal line raise touchdown and yardage outcomes. If George Pickens’ receiving yards are set at 66.5 and he lands on 70, the over wins. At 60, it is an under.

Miscellaneous player props

Some props span positions and reward specific outcomes.

Longest rush or longest reception asks whether a player will log a play beyond a posted yardage, so check big-play rates on both sides of the ball and how often a defense misses tackles.

Combo props bundle categories, such as rushing plus receiving yards or total touches, and fit versatile players who can produce in more than one way. You also see fantasy-scoring props, first to reach a stat, and head-to-head matchups.

season-long props

Futures cover a season or the playoffs, such as MVP, most passing yards, or stat leaders, so durability and team arc matter.

One missed week can sink an over, and playoff teams may manage snaps late if seeding is set. Schedule strength adds up over time. Runs of strong defenses lower totals, softer stretches can raise them.

A typical season wager might set a quarterback at 24.5 passing touchdowns. Throw 25 or more and the over wins. At 24 or fewer, the under does.

Parlay and combo NFL player prop bets

Parlays let you combine multiple props into one ticket, including same-game parlays built from a single matchup. Every leg must hit, risk rises with payout, but the math can work when the legs tell the same story.

For example, pairing a quarterback’s passing-yards over at +110 with his top receiver’s receptions over at -120 might yield +300. A $100 bet would return $300 if both legs hit.

Look for correlation. Heavy passing volume pairs naturally with receiver receptions, and pass attempts over can match with multiple pass-catcher overs. The reverse is also true. Conflicting legs, such as QB under 200 and a receiver over 100, lower your true hit rate.

Bigger tickets are tempting, but stacking too many good legs still compounds failure risk. Four legs at 60% each leave you around a 13% chance to hit. Payouts climb quickly, two -110 legs roughly return +260, three can reach +600, four can push +1300, but the sportsbook’s margin grows too, which is why experienced bettors use parlays sparingly and with a plan.

Promos can help on the edges. FanDuel, DraftKings, and Caesars often boost odds or sometimes give bonus bets back if on leg misses, which can tip a close edge in your favor.

However, whatver you do, DO NOT add unrelated legs just to qualify for a boost.

Can you place NFL player props live or in-game?

Yes. Live player props update during the game, and lines move in seconds as the situation changes. That speed can create chances if you spot a role change or matchup edge before the price moves.

For example, if a quarterback starts targeting a secondary receiver who was not in the pregame plan, you may find a favorable receiving-yardage over before it climbs.

Sportsbooks power these markets with real-time feeds, historical baselines, score and clock context, and weather.

Momentum matters. Sustained drives raise touches for backs and targets for receivers. Game script flips with the score, because teams that trail throw more, while teams that lead run the clock. Injuries are the biggest swing factor. If a shutdown corner leaves, the opposing receiver’s path to an over can open fast. If a starting receiver leaves, his backup may take routes before the model fully adjusts.

Red-zone patterns are another signal. Early tight end looks near the goal line can point to value on anytime touchdown or yardage overs. Use live trackers, alerts, and snap or target dashboards to stay ahead. Speed is the edge.

What are some key terms and conditions for NFL player props?

House rules decide how props are graded, voided, or refunded. So you should get to know them before you bet, so you don’t get surprised by a technicality.

Minimum participation / snap rules

Most books require a player to take at least one snap for action. If he is inactive or never plays, the bet is voided. If he logs a snap and then exits, the wager stands and is settled on whatever stats exist, even zero. Always confirm late statuses on game-time decisions.

Stat grading sources

Props settle on official NFL data or designated providers such as Elias Sports Bureau or STATS LLC to keep grading consistent. Edge cases happen, like unusual sacks or later stat corrections, but books typically grade on the stats available at settlement time, even if the league updates later.

Whether OT counts for prop bets

Overtime usually counts for player props unless a book states otherwise, which can swing close calls on yardage or receptions. Read the rules. Most include OT, but certain promos or books carve out exceptions.

Void/refund rules if a player doesn’t appear

If a player is ruled out or never takes the field, bets are generally voided and refunded. If he starts and then gets hurt, the bet is decided based on what happened before he left.

Props typically remain live if the game is rescheduled within a short window. If a defensive player is active but posts no stats, or an over loses, it is not void.

Unusual roles or trick plays can trigger book-specific clauses, so skim the fine print before you bet.

Bottom line, learn the settlement rules, track roles and usage, and you will approach these markets with hopefully fewer surprises and better results.

Timing, Strategy, and Bankroll Tips for NFL Player Prop Betting

Winning with NFL player props comes down to when you bet, how you size your wagers, and how you react to news. You mut have timing, strategy, and steady discipline all working together to protect your bankroll and grow it over time.

When are NFL player props released?

Player props usually land a few days before kickoff. For prime-time games, you’ll often see numbers as early as Monday or Tuesday, Sunday afternoon games usually appear by Thursday or Friday, while Monday night props may not show until the weekend.

That window matters because early lines can carry value before injuries or market moves change the price, yet they also carry risk if the news turns against you.

So what do you do with that?

Track release times and set alerts so you can act quickly on favorable numbers (beat writers and official reports help). Many experienced bettors focus on those early releases to grab mispriced props before the sportsbooks adjust.

Best times to place your bets (early vs. late)

Betting early can mean softer lines and better odds, especially for well-researched matchups. You might beat the market, but you also have to accept the risk of late injuries or depth-chart changes that can change odds sometimes dramatically.

Betting late gives you clarity, including final injury reports, weather, and scheme notes, though you’ll often pay for the certainty with worse prices.

A hybrid approach works for most. Bet early when you’re confident in the analysis, and hold off on situations tied to health or role until the information is clear.

Some books let you briefly hold a price while you research. Others offer alerts or short guarantees around key news. Use those tools so your number doesn’t slip while you confirm the details.

Shopping for the best first touchdown odds

First touchdown markets vary widely from book to book. One site might offer +700 on a player while another offer +850 for the same bet, and that gap adds up across a season and can be the difference between profit and loss.

Because first-TD is high variance, comparing odds is not optional, and can often be your only advantage. Use comparison tools or apps to surface the best numbers fast. Books price these differently (some weight red-zone usage or snap share more heavily), which is why you’ll see big differences.

Getting the top price consistently is one of the easiest ways to push your overall ROI in the right direction.

Managing your bankroll

Your bankroll plan is the seatbelt, boring until you need it.

  • Set a fixed unit size, usually 1–3% of your total bankroll, and stick to it so cold streaks don’t wreck your month.
  • Track every bet to spot patterns and tighten your process. A simple spreadsheet can reveal which prop types or timing windows actually pay you.
  • Don’t chase losses. It’s tempting to raise stakes after a rough day, but discipline protects your bankroll and your head.
  • Diversify across games and prop types to spread risk. Avoid piling everything on one player or game plan.
  • Set limits, stay consistent, and keep a long view. Swings happen, even for the best, but smart habits smooth them out.

Common mistakes to avoid when betting on NFL player props

Avoiding common mistakes is essential to improving your success with NFL player props. Here are the main errors and how to prevent them:

Betting without checking injury reports

Placing a bet without confirming player status is a fast way to lose value. Late scratches, snap counts, or “active but limited” tags can gut a prop.

Always verify injuries close to kickoff using official lists, beat reporters, and trusted trackers. Many bettors wait for confirmed lineups before touching questionable players.

Chasing recent trends or highlights

Did one big game push the line up? A standout performance can inflate averages while the median sits lower, and sportsbooks often raise numbers after prime-time highlights to attract casual bettors.

Focus on stable signals, such as usage, matchup, pace, and red-zone share, so you are pricing reality, not one hot game.

Over-stacking parlays

Every extra leg balloons risk. Even with four props each at a 60% chance, your projected combined win rate is only about 13%.

Keep parlays small (2–3 legs) and logically connected, for example a quarterback’s passing yards with his top receiver’s yardage, so the story holds together.

Plenty of winning bettors skip parlays entirely in favor of single bets with a clear advantage.

Forgetting to compare odds across books

Odds vary, sometimes by a lot. If one book posts +650 and another hangs +800 for the same player, taking the shorter price taxes your long-term results.

Maintain accounts at multiple sportsbooks and use comparison tools regularly. The habit is simple and the impact is real.

Misunderstanding how props are graded

House rules differ. Official stat sources, overtime treatment, and minimum participation can all change how a bet settles.

For example, some books don’t count quarterback kneel-downs as rushing yards, which affects rushing prop bets. So please read the rules before you bet, because understanding grading prevents surprises and will help you to make better decisions.

The bottom line is you have to be be disciplined, research thoroughly, track injuries, lean on stable metrics, keep parlays in check, shop lines, and know each book’s rules. Doing all this will protect your bankroll and boost your chances of long-term success.

Final whistle

NFL player props let you zero in on the details, including quarterback passing yards, running back rushing totals, and receiver target volume, to turn smart reads into real value. With the right tools and a clear plan, you might be able to convert insight into better prices and better decisions.

Profit doesn’t come from chasing hot streaks or stacking miracle parlays. It comes from disciplined research, sharp timing, and steady bankroll management. The best bettors compare odds constantly, stay on top of injury news, and know exactly how their wagers will be graded, so their advantage shows up where it should, in the results.

the PROP drop NEWSLETTER

Your one-stop resource for all things player props.

SUBSCRIBE NOW!

Recommended Bonuses Recommended Bonuses

BetMGM

First Bet Offer for New Customers Only

Up To $1500 Paid Back in Bonus Bets if You Don't Win

Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (Available in the US). Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), Call 1-800-327-5050 (MA), 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 1-800-981-0023 (PR). 21+ only. Please Gamble Responsibly. See BetMGM.com for Terms. First Bet Offer for new customers only (if applicable). Subject to eligibility requirements. Bonus bets are non-withdrawable. In partnership with Kansas Crossing Casino and Hotel. This promotional offer is not available in DC, Mississippi, New York, Nevada, Ontario, or Puerto Rico.

Fanduel

Bet $5, Get $300 in Bonus Bets If Your Bet Wins

NO PROMO CODE NEEDED

New Players Only, Must be 21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Must be Present in Legal State. Full T&Cs Apply. Please Play Responsibly.

Caesars Sportsbook

Bet $1, Double Winnings Your Next 20 Bets

Enter Code: PROPSCOM1000

21+ & Physically in Legal State, T&Cs Apply
Background