Best College Football Player Props – Top NCAAF Props (Weekly Update)

Tennessee Volunteers running back Jabari Small (2) runs for a touchdown against the Missouri Tigers during the first half at Neyland Stadium.
Image Credit: Randy Sartin-USA TODAY Sports

There’s a sizable edge when it comes to betting college football player props. With so many NCAAF teams to cover, sportsbooks are more likely to offer exploitable numbers compared to popular markets like NFL player props.

Making matters even better, the demand for college football player props is growing. More sportsbooks carry these wagers, and you can also make your NCAAF prop picks at Underdog Fantasy — which is legal in 40+ states.

Below, we’ll dive into our favorite college football player props for the week and let you know where these lines are available.

College Football Player Props: Week 4

We went 1-2 last week, but we are 4-3 on the season while still up 0.6 units. Let’s add to that in Week 4!

These picks come from DraftKings Sportsbook, and those are the ones that will show up on the overall record. However, you can place these college football props at Underdog Fantasy if DK is not available in your state.

Underdog Fantasy is legal in 40+ states. You can sign up using the promo code PROPS ($100 deposit match) through the link below:

Wisconsin RB Braelon Allen Over 0.5 Rushing TDs (-140)

Note: This game is scheduled for Friday, Sept. 22 at 7 p.m. ET.

Allen was a staple in our NCAAF props article last year, and this is an excellent price to bank on him once again.

As we all know, Wisconsin loves to run the football, and Allen has already cashed in with four touchdowns across three games played. Since the beginning of last season, he has scored 15 rushing touchdowns in his last 15 games played.

His opponent this week, Purdue, just gave up 271 rushing yards to Syracuse last Saturday. There’s a great chance the 245-pound runner will cross the goal line in this Big Ten matchup.

Where to Bet: Braelon Allen over 0.5 rush TD | -140 at DraftKings Sportsbook

Notre Dame RB Audric Estime: Anytime TD (-160)

If you have frequented this article, then you know that Estime has been a regular prop contributor for us. He has a must-watch matchup against Ohio State, and we could see plenty of scoring from both sides.

Estime has already contributed five touchdowns in four games this season, and he appears to be Notre Dame’s lead running back with Logan Diggs (transferred to LSU) no longer on the team.

Going back to last year, Estime has scored a touchdown in 10 of his last 12 games, and his role has only grown in the early part of the 2023 season.

Where to Bet: Audric Estime anytime TD | -160 at DraftKings Sportsbook

Tennessee RB Jabari Small Over 67.5 Rushing Yards (-115)

Small ran for 67+ yards in the first two games of the season. However, game flow went against him at Florida last week, as the senior running back only had 35 yards on seven carries.

Still, that translates to a healthy 5.0 yards per carry against a quality opponent. On the season, Small is averaging 6.0 yards per carry, which is something that could carry into this upcoming matchup against UTSA.

Game flow shouldn’t be an issue this time around, as Tennessee checks in as a 21.5-point home favorite. I’m expecting Small to get back to the level of his first two games this year, where he totaled 162 rushing yards on 26 carries.

Where to Bet: Jabari Small over 67.5 rushing yards | -115 at DraftKings Sportsbook

Want More NCAAF Props?

We occasionally send out exclusive College Football Props and NFL player props in our newsletter.

Click below to read more (for free), and subscribe if you would like to receive more prop picks like this.

2023 College Football Props Record

Spencer Limbach: 4-3 | +0.6 units
Justin Bales: 1-1 | -0.2 units

Where Can I Bet On College Football Player Props?

As mentioned earlier, college football player props are growing in popularity. However, betting on NCAAF props is still limited to only a few operators.

Here are the best places to find college football prop bets:

Also, check out these college football player prop alternatives for non-betting states:

What Is Underdog Fantasy?

Underdog Fantasy offers daily fantasy sports games and player prop pick’em contests in more than 40 states. That includes props for college sports. readers can sign up at Underdog Fantasy and claim a $100 deposit match offer.

  • The bonus features a 100% match on your first deposit, with just 1x playthrough required to unlock the full bonus.
  • You can use the Underdog Fantasy promo code PROPS to claim the welcome bonus.

Click here to view the 40+ legal states and claim your Underdog Fantasy $100 deposit bonus.

Types Of College Football Props

Let’s take a closer look at the different NCAAF prop bets that you can make. You might find some additional options at different sportsbooks, but these are pretty common.

College Football Player Prop Bet

A player prop bet is one of the most common college football betting options that you will see for each game throughout the season. The bigger games will have more markets available, while some of the smaller games might not have any at all.

NCAAF player prop bets focus on one specific player in a college football game and also on one statistical category. College football bettors will usually be betting on whether a certain player will reach a statistical milestone, or by how much.

Here are some examples:

  • Will Player X record at least 100 receiving yards in the game?
  • First player to score a touchdown: (List of all players)
  • Will Player X throw more than 2 passing touchdowns?

NCAA Football Team Prop Bet

A team college football prop bet is another option that you will commonly see offered in most college football games. This is a bet that is similar to a player prop bet, but it will involve looking at one specific team in a game.

There are times with a team prop bet that sportsbooks will put each team up against one another. Again, the bigger the game, the more team prop betting options you will see listed.

Here are some examples:

  • Will any team score at least 35 points in this college football game?
  • Team with more rushing yards: Alabama or LSU?
  • Will Ohio state record at least five sacks in the game at Michigan?

Season Long Prop Bets

A season-long prop bet is not like the first two options at all, as you won’t be focusing on just one individual college football game. Instead, you will be making a wager at the beginning of the season, and that result won’t be known until the year wraps up.

If you are a bettor that is familiar with making a “futures” bet, then this is a good NCAA football prop bet to focus on.

Some examples of a season-long prop bet might include:

  • Will any team from the “Group of Five” make it to the College Football Playoff?
  • Will two teams from the same conference reach the College Football Playoff?
  • Will a running back win the Heisman Trophy Award?

NCAA Football Prop Betting Tips

Even though betting on NCAA football props isn’t extremely difficult to do, it still isn’t one of the easiest betting types to cash in. There are some NCAA football prop betting tips that can help you be more successful, and three of those are outlined and discussed below.

Check For Injuries

One of the first things you will want to look at is the injury report. You want to look for players that might be sidelined by an injury, as that could affect how the prop bet plays out. Betting sites will be looking for this information as well, and this is where you could see some movement in the NCAA football prop betting odds.

Find The Value

As discussed above, sportsbooks continue to find and offer new college football prop betting markets. Betting sites want your action, and they will entice you to make a play by adding new props to the site.

While you should always be looking for prop bets that you can win, you also need to be looking for NCAA football prop bets that have some value. This means that you should be trying to identify a prop bet that has a good chance to cash, not necessarily just browsing for the “big games” or your favorite team.

You might have to dig deep and look really hard to find the most valuable NCAA football prop bet to make, but there will be some that are available to you. If you don’t think that a bet is valuable enough to make, then you simply need to wait for the next weekend and make a wager at that time.