Maple Leafs vs. Rangers Player Props, Picks and Predictions – Tuesday, Dec. 12

Oct 5, 2023; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Maple Leafs defenseman Morgan Rielly (44) shoots the puck against the Detroit Red Wings in the first period at Scotiabank Arena.
Image Credit: Dan Hamilton-USA TODAY Sports

We have your Toronto Maple Leafs vs. New York Rangers prop betting and game preview needs covered as the Toronto Maple Leafs hit the road to face the New York Rangers.

The New York Rangers (19-6-1) are set to host the Toronto Maple Leafs (14-6-5) in a highly anticipated matchup at Madison Square Garden. With the Rangers leading their division and the Maple Leafs not far behind in theirs, this game could be a critical point for both teams’ playoff positioning.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. New York Rangers Odds Info

Moneyline: Toronto Maple Leafs +130 (DraftKings) / New York Rangers -150 (FanDuel)

Puck Line: -1.5 – Toronto Maple Leafs -185 (Bet365) / New York Rangers +160 (DraftKings)

Total: 6 – +110 (DraftKings) / -130 (DraftKings)

Game Info

Date: Tuesday, Dec. 12

Time: 07:00 PM

Location: Madison Square Garden – New York City, NY

TV: ESPN+

Toronto Maple Leafs Betting Trends

  • On the road this season, the Toronto Maple Leafs have 6 wins and 6 losses.
  • As the underdog this season, the Toronto Maple Leafs have 1 win and 0 losses.
  • This season, the Toronto Maple Leafs have hit 14 overs and 11 unders.

New York Rangers Betting Trends

  • At home this season, the New York Rangers have 9 wins and 2 losses.
  • As the favorite this season, the New York Rangers have 16 wins and 5 losses.
  • This season, the New York Rangers have hit 11 overs and 15 unders.

Historic Head-to-Head Stats and Analysis

Over the course of the last two seasons, the Toronto Maple Leafs and the New York Rangers have faced off three times, with the Maple Leafs emerging victorious in two of those encounters while the Rangers claimed one win. These games were spread out across the regular season, with one game taking place on December 15, 2022, another on January 25, 2023, and the most recent on April 13, 2023. In terms of betting statistics, the Maple Leafs covered the spread once, while the Rangers did so twice. Interestingly, none of the games saw the total score go over the set Over-Under line, with all three games resulting in an under. The home team secured two wins compared to the visiting team’s single win. The Maple Leafs finished their season with a win percentage of 60.9756%, while the Rangers completed theirs with a slightly lower win percentage of 57.3171%. Key statistics from these matchups include the Maple Leafs’ 50 season wins and the Rangers’ 47, indicating a closely matched pair. The games were generally low-scoring, with the total score never exceeding the Over-Under line set by bookmakers.

The most recent game between the two teams on April 13, 2023, ended with a narrow 3-2 victory for the Toronto Maple Leafs over the New York Rangers. The game was characterized by a strong defensive performance from both sides, as reflected in the low number of shots on goal—21 for the Maple Leafs and 24 for the Rangers. The Maple Leafs had a slight advantage in faceoff wins, securing 27 against the Rangers’ 19. The Rangers, however, had more takeaways with 13 compared to the Maple Leafs’ 9. The game’s scoring was confined to the second and third periods, with Kaapo Kakko of the Rangers scoring in the second period, followed by a flurry of goals from Timothy Liljegren, Artemi Panarin, William Nylander, and Noel Acciari of the Maple Leafs in the third period. The goaltenders for both teams, Joseph Woll for the Maple Leafs and Jaroslav Halak for the Rangers, faced a moderate workload, with save percentages of 0.917 and 0.857, respectively. This game continued the trend of the under hitting, as the total score of 5 fell below the Over-Under line of 6.5.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. New York Rangers Predictions

The New York Rangers have been on a roll, currently sitting atop the Metropolitan Division with a strong home record of 9-2-0. They come into this game on a one-game winning streak, looking to leverage their home-ice advantage against the visiting Maple Leafs. The Rangers’ offense has been powered by left winger Artemi Panarin, who leads the team with 16 goals and 22 assists. Their defense has been equally impressive, contributing to their solid win percentage and positioning them as a formidable force in the Eastern Conference.

The Toronto Maple Leafs, third in the Atlantic Division, are aiming to rebound from a recent loss. With star center Auston Matthews leading the charge with 19 goals and right winger William Nylander contributing a team-high 21 assists, the Maple Leafs boast a potent offensive lineup that could challenge the Rangers’ defense. However, the Maple Leafs will need to be mindful of their road record (6-2-4) and look to improve their performance against top-tier teams like the Rangers.

This game is not just about the star players, as both teams have depth that could prove decisive. The Rangers’ strong defensive play and the Maple Leafs’ offensive prowess set the stage for an intriguing battle. Key player matchups, such as Panarin facing off against Matthews, and the goaltending duel, will be critical to the outcome of the game. With both teams looking to secure their standings and gain momentum as the season progresses, this matchup is poised to be a thrilling contest.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. New York Rangers Pick

The Toronto Maple Leafs are entering this game with a solid chance to upset the New York Rangers, despite the Rangers’ impressive record. The Maple Leafs’ road record of 6-2-4 demonstrates their ability to perform in away games, and with offensive leaders like Auston Matthews and William Nylander, they have the firepower to challenge the Rangers’ defense. Additionally, the Maple Leafs have shown resilience as underdogs this season, with a win already under their belt when not favored. Considering the Maple Leafs’ potential for high-scoring games, as indicated by hitting the over in 14 out of 25 games this season, their offensive might could be the key factor in overcoming the Rangers’ home-ice advantage.

Historically, the head-to-head matchups have been closely contested, with the Maple Leafs winning two out of the last three encounters. The most recent game was a narrow victory for the Maple Leafs, and with the team’s current form and the Rangers’ tendency to give up goals recently, this game could follow a similar pattern. While the Rangers are formidable at home, the Maple Leafs’ recent trends and the value presented by the +130 moneyline odds make them an attractive pick for this matchup. The Maple Leafs’ ability to perform on the road and their offensive threat are compelling reasons to back them in this game.

The Pick: Toronto Maple Leafs +130 (DraftKings)

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. New York Rangers Player Prop Picks

Here are the players who have hit over their current prop line in at least 7 of their last 10 games.

New York Rangers

Player Name Prop Line Over Rate Over Odds Under Odds Last 10 Average Projection
Jacob Trouba Shots On Goal 1.5 7/10 -166 +130 1.7 1.70
Mika Zibanejad Points 0.5 9/10 -175 +135 1.1 1.05
Vincent Trocheck Shots On Goal 2.5 7/10 -145 +114 3.2 3.06
Adam Fox Power Play Points 0.5 7/10 +120 -150 0.8 0.80
Adam Fox Points 0.5 7/10 -215 +165 1.1 1.07
Adam Fox Assists 0.5 7/10 -175 +135 0.9 0.86
Alexis Lafreniere Shots On Goal 2.5 7/10 +124 -160 3.2 3.19