Colts vs. Titans Predictions, Odds & Player Props – Week 5

Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson (5) and fellow members of the Colts offensive line look to the score board after a play ended in the Los Angeles Rams' favor during the first half of the game Sunday, Oct. 1, 2023, at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.
Image Credit: Jenna Watson/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK

Need a Colts vs. Titans prediction? We’ve got what you need, as the Titans hit the road to face the Colts on Sunday, Oct 8 at 1:00 ET. The current total stands at 43, with the Titans being favored by 2.5 as they play on the road.

Colts vs. Titans Odds

  • Spread: Titans -2.5
  • Total 43

Game Info

  • Date: Sunday, Oct 8
  • Time: 1:00 ET
  • Location: Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis IN
  • TV: CBS

Titans Betting Trends

  • Over their last five games, the Titans have an over/under record of 1-4 and are 4-1 vs. the spread.
  • Through their last five road contests, the Titans’ offense has averaged 11 points per game while allowing an average of 23. Tennessee posted an overall record of 0-5 while going 2-2-1 ATS.
  • Going back to their previous three games as the favorite, Tennessee has an ATS mark of 0-3 while going 0-3 straight up.

Colts Betting Trends

  • In their last five games, the Colts have an over/under record of 4-1 and are 0-5 vs. the spread.
  • In their last ten games at home, the Colts have a straight up record of 4-6 while going 5-5 vs. the spread. The team averaged 16 points per game in this stretch.
  • Looking back on the team’s last five games as the underdog, the Colts have a straight up record of 2-3. Their record vs the spread in these games was 2-3.

Can Tennessee Pull Out the Win as Road Favorites?

Through four games, the Titans are 2-2. In the AFC-South standings, they are in 4th place which puts them 10th in the AFC. The current scoring margin for the Titans’ is +0.5, and this has contributed to their ATS record of 3-1.

The last time Tennessee played, the Titans beat the Bengals with a final score of 27-3. While picking up the win, the Titans also covered the spread as 2.5-point underdogs. The under bettors were successful in the Titans’ most recent game, with a combined total of 30 points. The game’s betting line was 41.5.

The Titans’ offense produced a total of 400 yards against the Bengals. On third downs, the Titans achieved a conversion rate of 61.5%. Notably, Derrick Henry led the rushing attack with 122 yards, while Ryan Tannehill passed for 240 yards.

The Titans are currently 4th in tackles for loss and 4th in sacks on defense. Their opponents are scoring an average of 17.5 points per game and gaining 311.2 yards per contest against them.

Can Indianapolis Pull Off a Home Win?

Heading into week 5, Indianapolis is in 1st place in the AFC-South, sitting with an overall record of 2-2. In the AFC, they find themselves in 4th place. Thus far this season, the Colts hold a record above .500 against the spread, marked at 2-2. Their average scoring margin in the current season is -0.5.

This week, the Colts are hoping to bounce back from a 29-23 loss to the Rams. With a 6-point loss, the Colts added a loss to their ATS record as well. They were 1.5-point underdogs prior to the game. With a combined score of 52 points, the game surpassed the exceeded the pre-game over/under line of 44.5.

The Colts’ offense finished with 329 yards against the Rams and converted 30% of their 3rd down attempts. For the game, Zack Moss led the rushing attack with 70 yards, while Anthony Richardson passed for 200 yards.

When it comes to defense, the Colts have given up 263.8 passing yards and 126.8 rushing yards per game. In terms of sacks, Indianapolis ranks 3rd among other defenses. Coming into week 5, they have allowed 24.8 points per game and 390.5 yards.

Colts vs. Titans Player Prop

The passing yards prop for Tennessee quarterback Ryan Tannehill is sitting at 212.5. According to the odds, there’s a 53% chance that he will exceed this mark, with an under payout of -117.

When it comes to passing attempts among quarterbacks, Tannehill is currently positioned 20th. His season statistics include 788 passing yards and a completion percentage of 62.0%.

Given that he is facing a Colts defense that has done a good job putting pressure on the quarterback so far, I see Tannehill struggling to deal with the pressure of Indianapolis’ front seven. I’m taking the under at 212.5 passing yards.

The Prop: Ryan Tannehill Under 212.5 Passing Yards (-117)

Colts vs. Titans Predictions

Tennessee opened as 1.5-point favorites on the road, and the oddsmakers have since adjusted the lines to -2.5 in their favor.

In this game, I’m looking for Indianapolis to cover the spread as 2.5-point underdogs at home in a divisional contest.

Indianapolis showcased an effective ground game in their last matchup with Los Angeles, and I anticipate a similar performance this week. 

The Pick: Colts +2.5 | -111 at Fanduel Sportsbook

More NFL Props & Predictions 

Props.com is stepping up its game for NFL Week 5 by offering a range of articles focused on props and picks, like the following: