Looking for the best MLB props today? The Props crew compiles their favorite picks for every day of the baseball season.
Below are our top MLB player props across different categories like strikeouts, home run props, and total bases. We also have team MLB prop bets like NRFI props and same-game parlay picks included.
Top DFS Apps in All States
Best MLB Player Props Today – Wednesday, September 17
Our analysts have done their due diligence to pinpoint their best MLB props and DFS pick’em plays. Let’s see which baseball picks they like most today.
Editor’s Note: Follow our MLB news hub for more FREE expert picks, props, and analysis throughout the entire 2025 season! You can also head over to our Discord to chat with our experts and fellow bettors!
Jeremiah Jackson Higher Than 1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs
You have to scratch your head and wonder how Martin Perez keeps getting by. The veteran LHP will battle Baltimore on Wednedsay.
Similar to Patrick Corbin, there’s something bewildering about his ability to survive at the MLB level despite pitching to contact. At the same time, advanced metrics can’t support them continuing to pitch at a high level.
Perez is striking out right-handed batters at a 17% clip this year while getting barreled at a staggering 16% of the time against them.
Here’s the most glaring issue – Perez maintains an absurd .226 BABIP against righties, which is pretty unsustainable and lucky.
Enter the youngster, Jackson, who’s enjoyed a productive latter portion of the season for Baltimore.
During the previous 30 days, the emerging right-handed hitter has generated a strong .361 wOBA while pacing the club with a blistering 66% hard-contact percentage versus southpaws.
Jackson is making the most of his opportunities on a bad Baltimore team.
Where to play: Jeremiah Jackson Higher Than 1.5 Hits + Runs+ RBIs | Underdog
Matt Olson Higher Than 8.5 Fantasy Points
Olson and the Braves will dance with Brad Lord, who’s been ping-ponged between the bullpen and rotation for Washington this season. I don’t think this experiment can end soon enough.
While he showed competence as a reliever, the bat-missing ability simply wasn’t there, and this starting pitcher trial can’t conclude quickly enough for everyone involved.
Lefties have hit Lord for a .216 ISO while posting a solid .316 wOBA against him, and he’s getting barreled at an 11% rate.
On the surface, his 24% strikeout rate vs. LHB might look respectable, but when you dig deeper into his swinging-strike percentage and CSwhicc% metrics, the underlying indicators suggest regression is lurking.
Enter Olson, who’s been enjoying a renaissance summer and fall after an absolutely miserable beginning to the campaign.
The veteran first baseman has completely turned things around, currently leading Atlanta with a 16% barrel rate and an impressive .321 ISO vs. right-handed arms over the last 30 days. T
His 59% hard-contact rate against RHP during the recent stretch indicates he’s locked in and scorching the ball.
Where to play: Matt Olson Higher Than 8.5 Fantasy Points | Underdog
Top MLB DFS Pick’Em Apps
We love the MLB DFS pick’em projections available at top-flight daily fantasy sites like Underdog and Sleeper. They offer a very similar experience to player props.
You’ll often find a lot of value and strong payouts available at legal DFS sites. These apps are also available in many states that don’t yet have legal online sports betting.
- Underdog
- Sleeper
- Betr Picks
- Chalkboard
- ParlayPlay
- Dabble Fantasy
- Wanna Parlay
- Boom Fantasy
- DraftKings Pick6
Top Sportsbooks For MLB Props & Bets
The sportsbooks and daily fantasy sites featured in this article offer more than enough options to satisfy your MLB player props needs. As outlined before, always shop around for the best price.
You can’t go wrong with BetMGM, Caesars, and FanDuel Sportsbook when it comes to any kind of sports bet. Take a look at the following guides to see if these sportsbooks are legal in your state:
Top Sweepstakes Sites For MLB Props
Top MLB Prediction Market Sites
Kalshi is the first fully regulated prediction market in the United States dedicated solely to trading on the outcome of future events.
Interested in trying it out? Click the link above!
What Is A Player Prop?
A prop bet is a newer way to bet on sports in the US sports betting industry, but it has been around for a long time. Prop betting used to be only offered at the Super Bowl or other major sporting events, but that is no longer the case.
The term prop bet stands for a propositional bet, and it’s a wager that typically doesn’t have anything to do with the final score of a game. Prop bets can be made throughout a game, or you can extend this type of wager into a full season.
MLB Prop Options
Now that you understand the difference between fun and skill prop bets, you also need to know when and what betting options are available. Each sportsbook will have different MLB prop betting markets, but there are some very similar options that you will find as well.
MLB Player Prop Bets
Prop betting is dependent on the bettor as to which is the most popular option, but sportsbooks tend to offer more player prop betting markets than any other kind. A player prop bet is a wager placed on just one player, and it usually focuses on a specific statistic.
There are times that sportsbooks will put two players against each other to create a prop bet, but that is similar to what a DFS game looks like. Player prop betting usually focuses on the top players in each MLB game.
Here are some MLB player prop options:
- Will Gerrit have over/under 9.5 strikeouts?
- Will Kris Bryant hit a home run in this game?
MLB Team Prop Bets
A team prop is similar to an individual prop bet, but the wager focuses on an entire team rather than just one player. This is another prop betting option that will have more markets when a better matchup is being played.
Here are some potential team prop betting options that you would see at a sportsbook:
- Will the Chicago Cubs score over/under 5.5 total runs?
- Will there be a run in the first inning? Also known as NRFI or YRFI.
- The team that leads after 5 innings: Mets, Red Sox, or Tie
Full Season MLB Prop Bets
If you are a sports bettor who enjoys making futures bets, you will likely be interested in a full-season MLB prop bet. These are bets that don’t just cover one game in the season but take a look at the entire schedule in its entirety.
Both individual and team prop betting options will be included when it comes to a full-season MLB prop bet. These bets are usually open months before a season begins, and they might close once the games are underway.
Here are some potential options of what you might see:
- Best record in baseball: American League or National League
- Will any player win the Triple Crown? Yes or no
- Who will win the NL MVP or AL MVP?
Top Online Sportsbook And DFS Bonuses By State
Click on your state from the list below to see the best online sportsbooks and daily fantasy sites available in your area:
- Alabama
- Arizona
- California
- Colorado
- Florida
- Georgia
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Missouri
- Nebraska
- New Jersey
- New York
- North Carolina
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Pennsylvania
- South Carolina
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Virginia
- Wisconsin
MLB Prop Betting Tips
Now that you have a better understanding of how MLB prop betting works, it is time to take a look at some MLB prop betting tips that you can use to be successful.
Location Of Game
There isn’t a major home-field advantage when it comes to MLB games, but the location of a game does matter. Each ballpark is unique around baseball, and those different fields affect the MLB prop betting matchups.
You also need to check the weather for each game before placing an MLB prop bet as well. Most bettors always do this when betting on a baseball game, but it needs to be done when making an MLB prop betting wager as well.
Pitching Matchups
No matter what type of MLB bet you are looking to make, you always need to start your research by looking at the starting pitching matchups. Other factors determine an MLB game, but everything starts on the mound.
If you are betting on a particular batter’s performance in a game, you need to be sure that he isn’t facing one of the best pitchers in baseball. You also don’t want to make a player prop bet on a pitcher facing a tremendous offensive lineup.
Slumps vs. Streaks
Since the MLB season is so long, players and teams tend to go through long streaks at different season points. Looking at recent trends is one of the first things you will want to look at before making a prop betting wager.
These trends can always change, but finding out which players and teams are streaking and slumping can help you make successful MLB prop wagers. This can help in all forms of MLB betting, but it is especially true when focusing on props.
