10 Best Super Bowl Prop Bets 2024: McCaffrey Over, Kelce Under?

Christian McCaffrey #23 of the San Francisco 49ers warms up prior to the game against the Kansas City Chiefs at Levi's Stadium on October 23, 2022 in Santa Clara, California.
Image Credit: Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

Welcome to the Props.com guide on the Big Game, where we’ll outline our 10 Best Super Bowl Prop Bets 2024.

We’ve meticulously sifted through the noise to bring you the top picks to cover your Super Bowl prop betting needs for this matchup between the 49ers and the Chiefs.

10 Best Super Bowl Prop Bets 2024

In this comprehensive rundown, we’ve split our focus between Super Bowl player props — that zoom in on the performances of the players who turn the turf into their stage, and game props for those who prefer to gauge how the matchup itself will play out — like who will win, most first-half points, and total score.

Let’s run through our best Super Bowl prop bets 2024 below!

7 Best Super Bowl Player Props

Our staff is 15-9 while up 4.85 units in the NFL playoffs, and we have eight player props on tap for the Big Game.

You can view the full write-ups of these picks on our best NFL player props weekly hub page.

There’s also the no-brainer choice of taking Patrick Mahomes over 0.5 total yards on Underdog Fantasy. Here’s how it works.

Prop Special: Patrick Mahomes Over 0.5 Total Yards

This is a no-brainer NFL prop for NEW USERS of Underdog Fantasy for the Super Bowl.


Our partners at Underdog Fantasy are offering a promotion that allows you to take Patrick Mahomes over 0.5 total yards.

  • New customers can also get up to a $100 deposit bonus with promo code PROPS.
  • You can pair this with one of the aforementioned props or use our NFL cheat sheets for help.
  • This presents a fantastic opportunity to boost your bankroll.

3 Best Super Bowl Game Props

Our Props.com staff rounded up their favorite Super Bowl game props. Here are their picks.

Winner: Kansas City Chiefs (+110)

Analyst: Justin Bales

There are essentially two reasons that I’m taking the odds with Kansas City. I prefer Patrick Mahomes and Andy Reid to Brock Purdy and Kyle Shanahan. 

I’m not nearly as high on Purdy as virtually anyone else. He looked atrocious against Green Bay before turning the ball over against Detroit. There is always a point in the Super Bowl where the quarterback has to take the game over, and I much prefer Mahomes, who’s consistently done that, over Purdy. 

I truly believe that Shanahan could be the best offensive mind in the NFL. That’s a very real possibility. He’s also consistently shown that he isn’t a good in-game decision-maker. I much prefer Reid in this type of situation. 

Overall, I believe San Francisco has the better roster. I can’t overlook the odds and massive advantages Kansas City has at two of the most important spots in this type of game. 

Where to Bet: Kansas City Chiefs ML | +110 at FanDuel Sportsbook

Under 47.5 Total Points (-110)

Analyst: Josh Shepardson

Under 47.5 points is a betting-trends-influenced suggestion. The 49ers had only four games with totals of 47.5 points or higher. Two of those games went over, and two went under the total. 

However, the Chiefs were a printing press for unders this season. They had 14 of 20 games go under. Furthermore, Kansas City had seven games with a total of at least 47.5 points, and six went under the total.

Where to Bet: Under 47.5 total points | -110 at FanDuel Sportsbook

Over 23.5 First Half Points (+100)

Analyst: John Supowitz

Do not be surprised if this gets off to a fast start. Both teams are equipped with talented playmakers on the offensive side of the ball, and they put up points in a flash.

Although both have excellent defenses, don’t be surprised if they’re on their heels early on; both offenses are nearly averaging 15 points in the first half, which is top six in the NFL.

Where to bet: Over 23.5 First Half Points | +100 at DraftKings Sportsbook

Super Bowl Deal: $50 Protected Pick

This is a fantastic promotion for ALL USERS of Sleeper Fantasy for Super Bowl weekend.


Our partners at Sleeper Fantasy are offering up to a $50 protected pick starting Friday, Feb. 9 at 3 pm ET that runs until Super Bowl kickoff. 

  • If you don’t win your entry, they will refund your entry as promo funds up to $50. 
  • The promo will auto-apply to your first contest once the promotion is live (Friday, Feb. 9 at 3 pm ET)
  • You can only use this promotion once. So if you place a $5 contest, you will only have a $5 protected pick.

If you don’t have a Sleeper Fantasy account, you can grab two more bonuses along with the protected pick above. 

  • New user exclusive pick: Patrick Mahomes over 0.5 yards.
  • New customers also get up to a $500 deposit bonus with promo code PROPS.
  • Claiming all three offers presents a fantastic opportunity to boost your bankroll.

More Super Bowl Prop Bets 2024

Looking for more Super Bowl prop bets? We have everything you need, including touchdown scorers, Gatorade color predictions, and even a breakdown of the coin toss.

Best NFL Player Props – Top NFL Prop Bets (Super Bowl 58)

NFL Anytime Touchdown Scorer Predictions & Best Bets

First Touchdown Scorer Props – Who Will Score First TD Tonight?

2024 Super Bowl Gatorade Color Odds, History & Predictions (Not Red?)

Super Bowl Coin Toss: History & Where To Bet – Coin Toss Curse?